Dog Toy Safety Guide: What to Avoid and How to Choose Safe Toys
By Harry Barker | Luxury Dog Accessories and Products | Published: 2026-08-02
Category: Tips & Care
Learn how to keep your dog safe during playtime. This guide covers dangerous toy materials, choking hazards, and tips for choosing non-toxic, durable toys.
Playtime is one of the best parts of having a dog, but it comes with hidden risks. Every year, thousands of dogs are treated for toy-related injuries, from choking on small pieces to ingesting toxic materials. As a responsible pet parent, knowing what to avoid is just as important as choosing the right toy.
In this dog toy safety guide, we'll walk you through the most common hazards, what materials to steer clear of, and how to pick safe, durable toys that your pup will love. Whether you have a gentle chewer or a power chewer, these tips will help you create a safer play environment.
Common Dog Toy Hazards to Avoid
The biggest danger in dog toys is choking. Toys with small parts, like plastic eyes, squeakers, or stuffing, can be easily torn off and swallowed. Even toys that seem sturdy can break into sharp pieces if your dog is an aggressive chewer. Always inspect toys for loose parts and discard them if they start to fall apart.
Another major concern is toxic materials. Some cheap toys are made with harmful chemicals like phthalates, BPA, and lead. These can leach into your dog's system when chewed, leading to serious health issues. Stick to toys made from natural, non-toxic materials like organic cotton, natural rubber, or food-grade plastics.
Finally, beware of toys that are too small or too large for your dog. A toy that's too small can be swallowed whole, while one that's too large can cause jaw strain or dental damage. Always choose toys that are appropriately sized for your dog's breed and chewing style.
- Avoid toys with small parts that can be chewed off and swallowed.
- Steer clear of toys made with toxic plastics or synthetic dyes.
- Choose toys that are the right size for your dog's mouth and strength.
Safe Materials for Dog Toys
When it comes to safe dog toy materials, natural is best. Organic cotton and hemp are excellent choices for plush toys, as they are free from harmful chemicals and gentle on your dog's teeth. For chew toys, natural rubber is durable and non-toxic, making it a favorite among vets.
Food-grade silicone is another safe option, especially for toys that hold treats. It's soft enough to protect teeth but tough enough to withstand heavy chewing. Avoid toys made from PVC, which often contains phthalates, and be cautious with rawhide, which can be a choking hazard and is hard to digest.
At Harry Barker, we prioritize safety in every product. For example, our Tug and Toss Dog Rope Toy is made from natural cotton fibers, and our 6-Pack Rubber Ball Set uses non-toxic rubber. These are great choices for dogs who love to chew and play.

- Look for toys labeled 'non-toxic' or 'BPA-free'.
- Opt for natural materials like organic cotton, hemp, or natural rubber.
- Avoid toys with strong chemical smells, which often indicate harmful additives.
Choking Hazards: What to Look For
Choking is the most immediate danger when it comes to dog toys. Toys with squeakers are a common culprit, as dogs often try to remove and swallow the squeaker. If you choose a squeaky toy, make sure the squeaker is securely enclosed and monitor your dog during play.
Stuffing is another hazard. Plush toys can be torn open, and the stuffing can be ingested, causing intestinal blockages. If your dog is a heavy chewer, consider toys without stuffing, like our Floral Print Ostrich Dog Toy, which is designed to be durable and stuffing-free.

Always supervise your dog with new toys, especially if they are prone to destructive chewing. If you notice any small pieces or loose threads, remove the toy immediately. It's better to be safe than sorry.
- Check toys for loose parts before each play session.
- Avoid toys with small squeakers that can be easily removed.
- For aggressive chewers, choose toys without stuffing or with reinforced seams.
How to Choose Durable Toys for Heavy Chewers
If your dog is a power chewer, you need toys that can withstand serious abuse. Look for toys made from tough materials like natural rubber, nylon, or heavy-duty canvas. Avoid toys that are easily torn or broken, as these can become choking hazards.
Interactive toys like rope toys are great for heavy chewers because they satisfy the urge to chew while also providing a fun game of tug. Our Tug and Toss Dog Rope Toy is made from 100% cotton and is designed to be tough yet gentle on teeth.
For fetch lovers, a durable ball is a must. The 6-Pack Rubber Ball Set is perfect for heavy chewers, offering a non-toxic, bouncy ball that can handle rough play. Remember to rotate toys to keep your dog engaged and prevent boredom.
- Choose toys made from natural rubber or heavy-duty nylon.
- Avoid toys with thin plastic or flimsy materials.
- Rotate toys regularly to keep your dog interested and reduce wear.
Supervision and Toy Maintenance Tips
No toy is 100% indestructible, so supervision is key. Always watch your dog with new toys, especially if they are aggressive chewers. If a toy shows signs of wear, like cracks or loose pieces, replace it immediately.
Regular cleaning is also important for safety. Wash plush toys and rope toys in the washing machine, and wipe down rubber or plastic toys with a pet-safe cleaner. This prevents the buildup of bacteria and keeps toys safe for your dog.
Finally, store toys properly when not in use. Keep them out of reach when you're not supervising, and discard any toy that is damaged. By following these tips, you can ensure your dog enjoys safe, fun playtime.
- Inspect toys regularly for damage and wear.
- Clean toys according to the manufacturer's instructions.
- Replace toys that are broken or have sharp edges.
Keeping your dog safe during playtime doesn't have to be complicated. By avoiding dangerous toys, choosing safe materials, and supervising play, you can prevent accidents and ensure your furry friend stays happy and healthy. For a great selection of safe, durable toys, check out our Tug and Toss Dog Rope Toy – it's a perfect choice for interactive play.

